Battle for a Doomed City: Gaming Nanjing 1937 (Part 1)

gamex

This article is written by G. Jökull Gíslason, an Iceland-based wargamer and historian with a special interest in the Second Sino-Japanese War. It shows how wargames and simulations can add an extra dimension to the study of past events.

China in World War II has been a fascinating subject for me and I have been looking into designing Chinese forces for Flames of War. I have not been alone in this and the war in China has a lot to offer a dedicated modeller and wargamer. I have been designing a Battlegroup for Flames of War that focuses on the German trained Chinese Divisions that were the Elite of the Kuomintang Nationalist Revolutionary Army. These divisions were at the centre of the fighting in the first battles of the conflict in Shanghai and Nanjing.

During my research I have become friends with Peter Harmsen, the author of Shanghai 1937: Stalingrad on the Yangtze and Nanjing 1937: Battle for a Doomed City. These are easily two of the best books in English you can find on any battles in China during the war. Then by a stroke of fortune Peter came to Iceland to do two lectures and I invited him to my house for dinner and then a game of Flames of War. It would be the first battle for my newly painted Chinese and Japanese forces. Peter has never played a Flames of War battle before so I invited Brjánn to be his lieutenant. Luckily Flames of War is a straight forward game and everything works almost as you would expect so it is easy for a newcomer.

I selected the two armies and the battle is set on the Yuhuatai plateau south of Nanjing’s Zhonghua Gate. Here the NRA had set up trenches, barbed wire, pillboxes and barbed wire and the defences were manned by 3 divisions. One of them was the German trained elite 88th Division. Against them was the Veteran 6th IJA Division. The fighting around Yuhuatai was hard and inflicted heavy casualties on the Japanese. Even though Nanjing fell the battles here were more even. I offered Peter to choose which side he wanted and he opted for the Japanese attackers.

As both forces are predominantly infantry forces I decided to select Counterattack as the mission since it allows for fortifications and a mobile battle. The terrain was sparse on purpose since it was to reflect a fortified battle area. To assist in the assault the Japanese players elected to do a night attack so we fought using the Dawn rules.

THE CHINESE FORCES

game1

The Chinese Nationalist forces had received instructions from German military advisors since 1934. Most notable of these was Alexander von Falkenhausen. The Germans were to lead the Chinese military modernization and train the National Revolutionary Army to modern standards. Unfortunately only a few divisions had undergone such training when the conflict broke out but among them was the famous 88th Division. It had taken part in the heavy fighting in Shanghai and a strong detachment fought on the Yuhuatai plateau.

In addition to providing military advisors the Germans also supplied the Chinese with modern weapons. But China was poor and could only buy a limited number. Most of this was equipment was provided for Chiang Kai-shek’s elite divisions as you can see in the equipment of these troops.

Chinese deployment

game2

88th Division

National Revolutionary Army NRA

German Trained Infantry Battalion

Fearless Trained

HQ

1 CiC team and a Banner team

COMBAT COMPANIES

German trained Lián

2 rifle platoons

German trained Lián

2 rifle platoons

In Reserve

Heavy Machine-gun Lián

4x heavy machine-guns

WEAPONS COMPANIES

Mortar Lián

4x 81mm mortars

DIVISIONAL SUPPORT

Anti-tank Lián

2x 3.7cm PaK36

In Ambush

NRA Artillery Battery

4x 15cm sFH18

FORTIFICATIONS

Strongpoint

9 trenches & HMG nest

Strongpoint

– Not deployed

Barbed Wire

4 sections

Gun positions

Trench + 4 gun pits

Gun positions

Trench – 2 gun pits

– Not deployed

 

THE JAPANESE FORCES

game3

6TH Division

Imperial Japanse Army IJA

Hohei Chutai

Fearless Veteran

HQ

2x Command Sword teams

Regimental Standard

COMBAT PLATOONS

Hohei Platoon

3 Rifle squads and banners

 Hohei Platoon

3 Rifle squads and banners

WEAPONS PLATOONS

Hohei Battalion Gun plt

2x Type 92 70mm

SUPPORT PLATOONS

Hohei Rapid-Fire Gun plt

2x Type 94 37mm guns

Hohei Regimental Gun plt

2x Type 41 75mm guns and observer

Medium Sensha Company (2x plt)

HQ – 2x type 89 Chi-Ro and 1 type 94 TK

3x Type 89 Chi-Ro

 

BATTLE PLAN AND INITIAL DEPLOYMENT

The Chinese set up their strong point in a central position with one Infantry Company and both HMG and Mortar platoon in the same trenches. In front was a HMG nest. Inside the strongpoint was the defenders objective marker. On the right flank the heavy 15cm artillery was deployed. The 3.7cm guns were in ambush and the second Infantry Company was in reserve. The barbed wire was set up to delay any flanking moves by the Japanese.

game4

game5

Peter and Brjánn disagreed on the main plan. Peter was tempted to go for a frontal assault against the strong point but Brjánn thought that plan suicidal. The Japanese placed the other objective as far away from the Chinese strongpoint as possible and then they decided on Brjánn’s plan and deployed for a strong flanking manoeuvre towards it. They elected to go for a night attack to save them from the worst of the Chinese fire in the first turns.

The Japanese set up for a strong flanking manoeuvre against the undefended objective.

(To be continued)

Categories: Media, War

1 Comment

Leave a Reply